Skip to main content

Court chides AG over “act of vindictiveness” towards Exton Cubic



Accra High Court Judge today expressed his surprise at the failure of the Attorney General to hide its bias and vindictiveness towards local mining company Exton Cubic.

This is after he found that contents of one of the documents filed by the Attorney General were everything but helpful to the case he was supposed to determine.

Exton Cubic filed the certiorari application after the Minister for Lands and Natural Resources wrote a highly publicized letter on September 4, 2017 invoking three separate mining leases granted to the wholly Ghanaian owned company.

Exton Cubic in the application challenged the Lands Minister’s power to invalidate the licenses without first seeking the recommendation of the Minerals Commission and giving the lease holders a hearing.

Delivering a very eventful decision on the application today, the Presiding Judge Justice Ackaah-Boafo expressed his unhappiness with contents of a supplementary affidavit filed by the Attorney General.

Lawyers for Exton Cubic had first raised concerns about the said affidavit describing its contents as political and offensive.

They subsequently challenged the admissibility of the said document because it failed to raise any reasonable legal grounds.

Commenting on the issue the Justice Kweku Ackaah-Boafo said the document contained “emotive innuendos and not facts.”

He said the contents of the said supplementary affidavits exposed the government to suggestion that the cancellation of the leases was an act of vindictiveness.

The Judge also kicked against the AG’s suggestion that Exton Cubic should not have listed the Minister for Lands and Natural Resources as the Respondent in the matter.

The AG argued that she should have been named as Respondent but Justice Ackaah-Boafo said that would have been incongruent because the act being challenged was carried out by the Lands Minister and not the AG.

He described the AG’s suggestion as misconceived.

The High Court Judge also dismissed the claim that the Exton Cubic should have employed arbitration in resolving the disagreement with the State.

The AG argued that Section 27 of Act 703 mandated the mining company to first try to resolve the issue by employing Alternative Dispute Resolution.

Justice Ackaah Boafo however held that the AG’s position was flawed because she had already pleaded that Exton Cubic had no mineral right.

He said the provision in question only applied to a mineral right holder and that the AG cannot in breath claim the company had no right and in another breath ask the company to employ a procedure reserved for a right holder.

The Judge held that the right forum to hear the matter was the High Court.

Justice Ackaah Boafo ruled that the minister had no power to revoke the leases held by the company in such manner no matter what his intentions are.    

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sandy and Gibeleen's task; Improving sickle cell care

Two sisters Sandy Ayivor and Gibeleen Amponsah Ninpong are hoping to change the face of sickle cell care in the country within five years. This they hope to do through their GNS (Gibeleen & Sandy) Foundation. Ghana’s foremost sickle cell clinic is a one block facility comparable to the ones used as clinics in villages. The most worrying aspect is that the same facility is supposed to be the Ghana Institute of Clinical Genetics. The Institute is supposed to be the leading center for diagnosis and care for persons suffering from genetic conditions or ones inherited. Even though the Institute has some of the best brains in clinical genetics running and working in the facility, they have been reduced to providing only sickle cell care. A former Director of the Institute Dr. Edeghonghon Olayemi says the GNS Foundation first contacted the clinic and demanded to know the challenges of the company. He revealed that a list of the challenges confronting the ...
Post a Comment
Read more

SC to determine fate of "unexecuted" but "ratified" US-Ghana agreement

Barely three days after its ratification under controversial circumstances, the Defense Cooperation agreement between the Governments of the United States and Ghana is facing its first constitutional test. The agreement is the subject is a suit filed by Ashanti Regional Youth organizer of the National Democratic Congress Yaw Brogya Gyamfi. The government led by the Minister of Defence Dominic Nittiwul successfully pushed the agreement through parliament with the overwhelming support of all New patriotic Party MPs despite concerns over its constitutionality. The Minority led by its leader Haruna Iddrisu had questioned the suitability of the agreement for a parliamentary approval because it has not been duly signed and therefore does not meet the constitutional requirement of execution in order for it to be ratified. Article 75(2) which gives Parliament the authority to ratify agreements entered into by the executive reads; A treaty, agreement or convention executed by...
1 comment
Read more

Anger; new income tax measure takes toll on Judges salary

Anger is brewing in the judiciary over the impact of mid-year tax measures on the salaries of judges. It would be recalled that government announced a 35 percent tax on persons earning over 10,000 cedis as part of measures to rake in more revenue. Even though the move has been hailed as forward looking, Gold News understands it is affecting the living conditions of judges. Article 127(5) of the 1992 Constitution states; “The salary, allowances, privileges and rights in respect of leave of absence, gratuity, pension and other conditions of service of a Justice of the superior court or any judicial officer or other person exercising judicial power, shall not be varied to his disadvantage.” This constitutional provision, I am made to understand imposes an obligation on government to ensure that its policies do not unduly negatively affect the living conditions of judges but that seems not to be the case at this time. Information I have gathered indicates  some judges ar...
Post a Comment
Read more